S. D. V. Stephens

notes /

Critical Theory

Notes on Peter E. Gordon’s lecture course on Frankfurt School critical theory (Harvard, spring 2026): Lukács, Horkheimer, Benjamin, Adorno, Marcuse, Habermas, Fraser, and after.

Each lecture’s page joins two sources: Professor Gordon’s handout for the day, and what I wrote down in the room. The handout’s outline is reproduced, folded, at the foot of the page; the quotations on its back appear in the text as callouts, at the point where the lecture cites them by number; and the handout itself is linked under Readings. My notes are rewritten as continuous prose, as if the lecture were being given again. Some lectures have both sources, more have only the handout, one has only my notes, and the last few have neither, so their pages just list the readings.

Music for the day. Some lectures opened with a piece of music. Where there was one, it is named under the lecture’s title, with a link to a recording.

Readings. Each lecture lists its assigned readings and the day’s handout. A PDF marked locked sits behind a password; ask me for it. Where a reading is also free online (at marxists.org, say) or can be borrowed from the Internet Archive, that link is there too. For the two books on the syllabus, Dialectic of Enlightenment and Redistribution or Recognition?, only the assigned chapters are posted.

Pronunciation. The first time a German, French or Latin word (or a name that English readers often trip over) appears in these notes, a sounds-like spelling follows it, once, with the stressed syllable in capitals: for example Geist (GUYST). After that the word appears on its own. In the respellings, kh is the German ch of Bach, ew is a French u or German ü (say ee with rounded lips), ur is a German ö (say ay with rounded lips, no r), and zh is the s of measure.

18 of 25 lectures written

week 1Introduction

  1. 1
    Introduction
  2. 2
    Marxism in Transition

week 2The Origins of Hegelian Marxism

  1. 3
    Marxism and Dialectics
  2. 4
    Consciousness and Reification

week 3Foundations of the Institute for Social Research

  1. 5
    Horkheimer and the Re-Founding of the Institute
  2. 6
    The Early Definition of Critical Theory

week 4Delineations of Critical Theory

  1. 7
    The Introduction of Psychoanalysis
  2. 8
    The Social Psychology of Family and State

week 5The Politics of Mass Culture

  1. 9
    Beyond Bourgeois Aesthetics
  2. 10
    Mass Culture and the Commodity Form

week 6History and Reason

  1. 11
    Benjamin’s Angel
  2. 12
    Dialectic of Enlightenment

week 7Fascism and Authoritarianism

  1. 13
    The Authoritarian Personality
  2. 14
    Psychoanalysis and Mass Society

week 8The Problem of the Culture Industry

  1. 15
    A Wholly Commodified World?
  2. 16
    Culture and Its Dialectic

week 9The Student Movement

  1. 17
    Marcuse in the 1960s
  2. 18
    Resistance and Resignation readings only

week 10Critique and Communication

  1. 19
    Habermas’s Critique of the First Generation readings only
  2. 20
    The Presuppositions of Communicative Reason readings only

week 11Contestations in Critical Theory I

  1. 21
    Gender in Critical Theory
  2. 22
    Decolonizing Critical Theory readings only

week 12Contestations in Critical Theory II

  1. 23
    The Recognition Debate readings only
  2. 24
    Redistribution or Recognition readings only

week 13Perennial Questions

  1. 25
    What Can Critique Still Mean? readings only