S. D. V. Stephens

notes / Studies in Real and Complex Analysis / chapter 4: The Fundamental Group and Covering Spaces

15 Covering Spaces and Path Lifting

· Denis Auroux

Original Professor Auroux’s handwritten notes (PDF), behind a password for now:

At some point we’d like to show . We’ll do this by introducing a key tool for the study of : the notion of covering spaces.

Covering spaces

Definition 15.1 (Evenly covered). Let be a continuous surjective map. We say evenly covers an open subset if where the are disjoint open subsets, and for each , is a homeomorphism. The are called slices.

A stack of disjoint orange slices making up p^{-1}(U), each mapping homeomorphically by p onto the red open set U below.

(Equivalently: there is a homeomorphism , with given the discrete topology, such that : We say the diagram of maps commutes.)

Definition 15.2 (Covering space). If every point of has a neighborhood which is evenly covered by , we say is a covering space of and is a covering map. is called the base of the covering.

Example 15.3. If is any topological space and a set with the discrete topology, then is a covering map.

The trivial covering: several copies of X stacked as X x A, projecting down onto X.

Example 15.4. , , is a covering map! E.g. take (or any arc of the circle). Then and is a homeomorphism on each slice.

The real line drawn as a helix over the circle, with the preimage of the right half-circle U marked in red as disjoint arcs, one per turn.

Example 15.5. Consider . Then , (so ), is an -fold covering.

A circle is homeomorphic to a doubled loop that wraps twice around and maps down onto a circle by z -> z^2.

Theorem 15.6. If and are covering maps, then is a covering map.

Proof. Given , let and be neighborhoods such that and (slices). Then a union of open slices homeomorphic to . ∎

Example 15.7. Consider the torus : since covers , covers .

A square grid in the plane with lattice points (0,0), (2pi,0), (0,2pi) mapping by p x p onto a torus.

If is a covering and a subspace, then by restriction we get a covering .

Example 15.8. Let be a base point on the circle, and let . Then is the “figure eight space” .

A torus with a longitude circle and a meridian circle meeting at (b,b); their union is the figure eight S^1 v S^1.

Then we have a covering , where The horizontal lines map to one circle and the vertical lines map to the other.

The grid of horizontal and vertical lines through multiples of 2pi in the plane maps by p x p onto the figure eight: horizontal lines go to one circle, vertical lines to the other.

Lifting

Definition 15.9 (Lifting). Given a continuous map , a lifting of a continuous map is a map such that , i.e. the diagram

Commutative triangle: f from X to B, the covering p from E to B, and the dashed lift f-tilde from X to E.

commutes.

If is a covering map, then we can locally lift: namely, if and is evenly covered, then we can lift to one of the sheets.

Key point: if is a covering, then paths and path homotopies in always lift.

Example 15.10. Consider , , and the path , . This has infinitely many possible lifts to paths in , depending on where gets lifted to.

The upper half-circle path f in S^1 and some of its lifts to the real line, the red segments [-2pi,-pi], [0,pi], [2pi,3pi].

Theorem 15.11 (Path lifting). Let be a covering map, a path starting at , and . Then there exists a unique lift such that .

Proof. Cover by open sets which are evenly covered by . Then the preimages are an open cover of , which is compact, so there exists a Lebesgue number such that for all , for some . Hence we can find a finite subdivision such that each lies inside one of the .

Define . Assume we have defined for . Then we define for as follows. Recall for some which is evenly covered by , slices. Let be the slice which contains . The map is a homeomorphism, so it has a continuous inverse, and we can define which extends continuously over . Repeating the process, we obtain a continuous lift .

is unique since for each there was a unique slice containing and a unique way to lift into it. ∎

Theorem 15.12 (Homotopy lifting). Let be continuous with , a covering map, and . Then there exists a unique lift such that .

Proof. The proof is exactly the same: subdivide into squares of side length which map into open subsets of that are evenly covered; then construct the lift one square at a time. ∎

Proposition 15.13 (Observation). If is a path-homotopy from to (in ), then is a path homotopy (in ) from to .

Indeed, if for all , then , which is a discrete subset of (one point in each slice), so we must have for all (always the same point). Similarly for the other endpoint .

On the other hand, loops don’t always lift to loops!

Example 15.14. A loop going once around the circle from lifts to a path in starting at and ending at , which is not a loop.

A loop f around the circle based at b0 lifts to a path in the real line from 0 to 2pi, which is not a loop.

But since path lifting is unique, given a starting point , the endpoint is uniquely determined. This leads to a key notion:

Notes not reached in this lecture, covered at the start of Lecture 16

The lifting correspondence

Definition 15.15 (Lifting correspondence). For a covering , the lifting correspondence is defined by , where is the lift of such that .

Question 15.16. Why is well-defined? (I.e. independent of the choice of in its homotopy class?)

Show solution

If is a path homotopy , then its lift starting at is a path homotopy between and , so .

Example 15.17. For the covering , taking and : if loops around the circle times (counting counterclockwise), then its lift ends at . This gives a map (surjective).

Now we know, at last, that isn’t simply connected!

Proposition 15.18. If is path connected, then is surjective.

Proof. Let , and a path from to . Then is a loop at whose lift starting at is . So . ∎

Recall:

Proposition 15.19. If is simply connected, then any two paths from to are path-homotopic.

Proof. is a loop at , so ( simply connected). Then ∎

So:

Theorem 15.20. If is a covering and is simply connected, then is a bijection.

Proof. By the above, is surjective. If , then are paths in starting at and ending at the same point . Since is simply connected, . Hence , i.e. , so . So is injective. ∎

Theorem 15.21. .

Proof. Consider the covering map , . Since is simply connected, by the above theorem the lifting correspondence is a bijection. We just need to show it is a group homomorphism.

Let and let , ; i.e. the lifts and starting at end at and . Define a new path by : this is the lift of starting at . Then is a well-defined path in from to , and it is the lift of starting at . So ∎

(One can show similarly that for the torus, , using the covering .)

The Brouwer fixed point theorem

Next we study applications of .

Let denote the closed ball of radius in , with boundary the unit sphere . Recall that if , a retraction is a continuous map such that for all .

Theorem 15.22. There is no retraction of onto .

The closed disk B^2 with arrows pushing outward toward the boundary circle S^1, with base point x0 on the boundary.

Proof. If is a retraction, then , so where because is convex in (straight-line homotopy). Then is the trivial homomorphism, which is . Contradiction. ∎

(A more elementary way to say this: given a nontrivial loop in , is nullhomotopic in , via some homotopy from to . Then is a path-homotopy in , contradiction.)

[With more algebraic topology, similarly there is no retraction for all .]

This implies:

Theorem 15.23 (Brouwer fixed point theorem). If is continuous, then there exists such that .

[With more algebraic topology, the same holds for continuous maps for all . The case follows from the intermediate value theorem, cf. HW2.]

Proof. Assume is continuous and for all . Then define by mapping each to the point where the ray from to hits .

Inside the unit disk, rays from f(p) through p and from f(q) through q extended until they hit the boundary circle at h(p) and h(q).

(Formula: , where is such that . We can solve for by the quadratic formula, so does depend continuously on .)

This gives a continuous map ; moreover, if then , so we get a retraction . Contradiction. ∎